Rick Weinmeyer argues that the city should partner with local businesses to make their toilets available free of charge, while also installing more automated pay toilets.
Over twenty-five years ago, the beloved N.Y. Times reporter Clyde Haberman observed that there were few things that couldn’t be done in the city that never sleeps: you could “travel its length on . . . a single subway token,” “pray in an astonishing variety of houses of worship,” or even “hire someone to play the Mendelssohn march on a kazoo at your daughter’s wedding.” But the one thing you couldn’t do, he lamented, was “find a public toilet if you happen to be on the street when nature calls.” Unfortunately, for Haberman and his fellow New Yorkers, not much has changed in the intervening quarter-century.
It is certainly not for a lack of ideas. New York is a veritable graveyard of past policy proposals meant to address its toilet crisis, as previous administrations have sidelined toilet installation projects when confronted with the quotidian hassles of urban bureaucracy and politics. Toilets are, after all, an easy public policy topic to cast aside when municipal budgets are tight and unexpected challenges compete for attention and resolution.
They are also expensive, a fact the current administration knows all too well. During only his second week in office, Mayor Zohran Mamdani committed four million dollars to installing modular toilets across the city’s five boroughs. This would create approximately two dozen temporary toilets, complete with changing tables and sinks, in seventeen bustling parts of New York. And in June 2026, the City announced the launch of a $19.3 million project to install five permanent public toilets in parks in Manhattan, Queens, and the Bronx.
That price tag might seem shocking for the small number of facilities that will be created, but toilets are not just toilets. As the manager of San Francisco’s Recreation and Park Department revealed during a public debate over the cost of public toilets in that city, “they are buildings and subsurface infrastructure that include concrete pads, accommodations for plumbing and electrical utilities and fixtures, lighting inside and outside, accessible walkways, landings and railings and sometimes retaining walls—all in addition to the structure that encompasses ‘the toilets.’” Moreover, to install a single toilet, cities must undertake planning, propose budgets, seek public feedback, and obtain permitting approvals, all before construction and installation happens.
Fortunately, thanks to laws and policies implemented by the Adams administration and City Council in recent years, the Mamdani administration is well positioned to tackle these challenges and expand toilet availability and accessibility. To do so, however, it will need to pursue measures that no one US jurisdiction has effectively undertaken.
Public-Private Pursuits
On April 10, 2025, the New York City Council enacted Local Law 58, which establishes a long-term strategic planning process for the creation and maintenance of the city’s public toilet network. The plan assigns oversight to a Deputy Mayor of Operations who will work in collaboration with the heads of multiple city departments with expertise in maintaining and operating toilets, including City Planning, Parks and Recreation, and Transportation. The ultimate goal is to establish at least 2,120 total public toilets across the city by 2035 (more than doubling the 1,036 toilets that already exist in the city). In addition, the law requires a strategic planning report every four years to address capital strategy recommendations, propose changes to law and policy to support the opening or conversion of toilets, and identify sites for new toilets.
The law also includes a key provision to harness existing infrastructure throughout the city that, if effectively implemented, could expand the city’s toilet supply exponentially. The provision requires the government to consider recommendations for new toilet locations in facilities that are either “publicly or privately owned” and where toilets already exist or could be “converted to public bathrooms through public-private partnerships, agreements, or programs.”
Utilizing existing toilets is a fairly standard feature of municipal toilet proposals, yet to this day, no American city has successfully undertaken such a step. For example, in 2018, Washington, D.C., enacted a law that, in part, included a “Community Restroom Incentive Pilot Program,” under which the city would work with a select business improvement district to “make their restrooms available free of charge to any person, regardless of whether the person patronizes the place of public accommodation.” This program never materialized, unfortunately, for a number of reasons, including a lack of political commitment, Covid-era economic pressures, and concerns about crime in D.C.’s commercial areas.
Other international cities have found a modicum of success with public-private toilet programs. For example, under the United Kingdom’s Community Toilet Scheme, various London boroughs work with the businesses in their jurisdictions to provide free toilet access to residents. The local council provides financial compensation to participating businesses to cover cleaning and maintenance, and businesses retain the right to refuse entrance only under exceptional circumstances. Businesses that participate, moreover, promote their civic deeds by displaying stickers on their premises and including their locations in online toilet maps.
New York has, to some degree, already weathered some of the challenges that public-private toilet partnerships can bring. In 2021, amidst stay-at-home orders and the skyrocketing request for delivery services, delivery workers organized for the right to use the toilets of the businesses they delivered for. The notion initially met with vocal backlash. When a non-binding resolution to grant toilet access to delivery workers was introduced on the Upper West Side, one community transportation board member decried the proposal as “crazy” (three times), while another called it “horrifying on all levels.” Yet a similar amendment to the city’s administrative code was later enacted by the City Council, requiring a toilet access provision in all contracts between third-party food delivery services and food service establishments. While businesses and private property owners have legitimate concerns about who uses their toilets, compensating businesses to open their facilities and providing waivers of civil liability could help to assuage that friction, similar to what has been done in London.
Paying to Pee and Poop
The city could also defray the financial burden of toilets by looking more directly to the peeing public. One idea that Law 58 acknowledges, yet does not engage, is pay toilets. This oversight is understandable. Pay toilets have a complicated history. They have been condemned on the grounds that requiring someone pay to urinate or defecate is a violation of human rights, and, in places where urinals but not stalls are free, as a form of sex discrimination. And like many states, New York banned the operation of pay toilets in 1975, amidst a widespread effort to eliminate these venues across the country.
New York City, however, already has a pay toilet exemption. In 1993, the New York Assembly passed legislation granting the city a waiver from the state’s prohibition, so that the city could undertake a pilot project that involved the installation of one hundred coin-operated toilets across the city. While several attempts at launching pay toilet programs stalled out over the subsequent decades, New York currently has pay toilets operating in the city, and it should increase their number dramatically.
The primary argument for pay toilets is that they have the potential to pay for themselves. For example, when the Mayor of Chicago implemented a pay toilet ban in 1973, the closure of pay toilets at the city’s three airports meant the loss of a reported $125,000 to $225,000 in municipal revenue. In New York, the city government’s current agreement with the urban design firm JCDecaux includes the installation of up to forty pay toilets, yet at this time, only seven automated pay toilets are in operation. The combination of user fees and advertising revenue makes these units potentially cost-effective facilities, as this money can be used for toilet maintenance and upkeep to ensure they remain accessible and desirable. More toilets should be installed to meet the current agreement, and in fact, the city knows this: the Department of Transportation already has in place a request form to identify potential locations for future toilets, and the government takes those requests seriously.
While pay toilets will be considered by some to be discriminatory towards those who cannot afford to pay, so long as the city treats these as a supplemental rather than primary method for providing public toilets, their presence will serve to expand access for all by increasing revenue and ensuring that existing (free) toilets are not overburdened. Furthermore, the city can waive the cost of entry for those who do not have the ability to pay, similar to how the city is expanding access to modular toilets.
Moving Forward
On August 12, 2026, Deputy Mayor of Operations Julia Kerson sent a letter to the New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin, updating her on the progress of Law 58’s first mandated strategic planning report: it was “backed up.” As Kerson stated, revamping the city’s toilet system is complex and requires “extensive cross-agency coordination . . . to establish a reporting framework, compile baseline data, and develop a substantive strategy.”
Providing toilets to a metropolis of more than eight million residents and sixty-five million annual visitors is going to be complicated. Every past administration has failed to meet this challenge, often because of costs, bureaucratic hurdles, or just ineptitude (Mayor Bloomberg famously and cavalierly suggested just going to Starbucks). But with Law 58 and the tools it provides, as well as the opportunity to pursue supplemental reforms like pay toilets, New York City should be able to offer more people the simple dignity of having somewhere to go.
Rick M. Weinmeyer is an assistant professor of law at Loyola University Chicago School of Law.



