For observers of European politics in recent years, Spain has stood as an anomaly. With the continent’s only progressive governing coalition, Spain has gone against the grain on everything from trade protectionism and Trump to its commitment to the International Court of Justice and the International Criminal Court. Even more strikingly, Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez’s domestic agenda has broken with the continental pattern of reaction against migrants, all while managing the inflation shock and ushering in a period of robust public investment, high economic growth rates, minimum wage increases, and expansive social and labor reforms.
Many of the government’s signature policy achievements have been squarely focused on reigning in the cost of living—on affordability. To understand the approach behind this agenda, and what lessons it might hold for New York City, we spoke with one of its leading champions, Pablo Bustinduy, Minister of Social Rights, Consumer Affairs, and the 2030 Agenda.
Jack Gross: Minister Bustinduy, thank you for taking the time. You lead the Ministry of Social Rights and Consumer Affairs in Spain, which has become central to the government’s approach to affordability and fundamental economic inequalities. During your tenure as Minister, what have you learned about politics and policy making?
Pablo Bustinduy: Thank you for inviting me. If there is one central idea I always return to, it is this: a democracy cannot function if the basic coordinates of social life are subordinated to the will and interests of a handful of powerful corporations and wealthy individuals. When wealth is so concentrated that it shapes markets, public space, and even the choices available to regular families, the result is that the majority live in permanent uncertainty while a minority craft the rules to suit themselves.
In response to this, I focus on three pillars for policy making. The first is shifting power back toward the many: in housing, in consumer rights, in the way digital platforms work. The second pillar is building universal rights such that outcomes do not depend on luck or income: this includes rights to care, to raise a child in dignity, to grow old with autonomy, to live in a home that is not a financial asset for someone else. The third pillar is understanding that social justice is not an abstract idea: it must be legislated and enforced. And it must be built step by step, through both regulation and public investment.
JG: Housing remains the number one concern for New Yorkers in terms of monthly costs, and is also the driver behind working class people leaving the city in droves. You’ve intervened decisively in Spain against abusive rental agencies and against illegal short-term rentals. What lessons might we draw from that experience?
PB: Housing is where the fight for equality becomes tangible. After the pandemic, Spain implemented one of Europe’s strongest anti-eviction moratoriums, because we believed no family should lose their home during a public health crisis. More recently, we forced rental agencies to stop charging illegal fees and compelled platforms like Airbnb to remove thousands of unlicensed listings that were draining long-term housing from neighborhoods. Making housing affordable is not a straightforward technical question but a political one, and therefore pressure and regulation must be continuous and extended over time. For example, we are continuing to work on new proposals aimed at curbing speculative investment, limiting abusive rent increases, and strengthening long-term rental markets.
One of our main proposals right now is the extension of the rental contracts that were put into place during the Covid-19 pandemic. We are talking about more than half a million contracts coming to an end this year and the next. We know that, given current market prices, landlords will be ending their existing contracts to offer new ones at a much higher price, impacting thousands of families who can barely afford their current rent. Our proposition is simple: extend those contracts while freezing their prices. We hope we can make this possible very soon.
At the end of the day, the most important lesson is to never forget that when we talk about housing, no matter how much some economic and political agents may be interested in the opposite, we are not talking about assets and properties; we are talking about families and about communities that bring life to our neighborhoods and cities. Those people need protection and certainty; hedge funds and real estate companies do not.
JG: You’ve also advanced new consumer protections in Spain—regulating algorithms, unfair subscription practices, spam calls, and restrictions on profiteering during disasters. (And you’ve invited serious corporate attacks in response to those efforts.) Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Consumer and Worker Protection Commissioner Sam Levine have also pursued similar actions in their first weeks in government. Can you tell us more about this aspect of your work, and how it may translate to the municipal context in the US?
PB: These reforms come from the recognition that unequal power in digital and consumer markets generates new forms of inequality. The goal is not merely to prevent abuse but to rebalance the distribution of power between individuals and the companies that shape their daily lives. For example, we are requiring companies to explain the algorithms that determine pricing or access to essential services, especially in digital markets where opacity is the norm. We banned companies from raising prices to profit from natural disasters or infrastructure failures. We mandated clearer rules for subscription renewals, limited unsolicited commercial calls, and set maximum waiting times for customer service. We are seeking regulations that forbid discrimination by algorithms and new artificial intelligence technologies against people with disabilities. In a city like New York, where digital platforms mediate everything from groceries to apartments, algorithmic transparency can protect consumers from invisible forms of discrimination. That is the key point, which sometimes gets lost in the headlines around our fights for consumer protections: stronger consumer rights mean that families don’t lose money simply because a company designs its systems to confuse or trap them.
JG: Universal childcare has become a consensus political goal in New York. But forging durable political coalitions for care policy—for the elderly, people with disabilities, and families with children—is a major challenge. Spain is promoting a model of care that keeps people close to their communities. Can you tell us more about the government’s agenda on care policy?
PB: We are trying to build a new social contract for care. A new social care strategy that recognizes that dependency, aging, disability, and childhood are not private misfortunes but universal human experiences.
For example, for people with ALS, we passed a bill funding round-the-clock care provided by small, stable teams of caregivers. Specifically, we introduced a new category into our long-term care system that enables people with ALS and other complex illnesses to access specific forms of aid. This allows us to reinforce the long-term care system as a whole while, at the same time, moving toward more personalized care.
Along the same lines, for older adults, we are moving away from large, institutional residences toward local, community-based services that allow people to remain in their homes or neighborhoods. We have invested heavily in telecare (or remote assistance), which allows us to offer better care for the elderly while enhancing their ability to stay in their homes for as long as they wish, connected to their communities.
For families, we have expanded parental leave, which now reaches nineteen weeks. This leave is equal for both mothers and fathers, non-transferable, and mandatory during the first weeks of the child’s life. Moreover, we’re building a new universal child benefit, proposing 200 euros a month for every child from 0 to 18 years; universal, without bureaucracy or barriers. We know that our current social protection system is not reaching the most vulnerable families in our country, and we want to establish the right to care during childhood as a universal citizenship right, not as a subsidy.
Any progressive project, whether at the municipal level, as in the case of New York, or at the national level, faces the great challenge of building communities of welfare in times of geopolitical and local conflict. It is a huge challenge, but in order to face it, we must adapt our welfare state to a new era: that of universal citizenship rights. This is what we are doing, and we hope that New York City will join us in this approach.
JG: Can you say more about parental leave and the child benefit? How do you understand the relationship between these policies?
PB: As I mentioned before, we extended statutory paid parental leave to nineteen weeks—something you do not have in the US—which includes dedicated weeks later in early childhood, because the needs of families do not end after infancy. We encourage both parents to be equally involved by making the leave compulsory and non-transferable. In fact, Spain is one of the only countries in Europe where parental leave is equal for mothers and fathers; in our country, this measure has proven to be very effective in reducing gender gaps in the labor market.
While there has been significant progress in professional equity, women continue to take on primary caregiving responsibilities within the family. Without robust public investment and sufficient financial support for families, this care gap continues to hinder women’s professional advancement and economic independence.
In conclusion, childcare must be affordable, accessible, and treated as a right. Whether through direct subsidies, expanded public childcare centers, or universal cash benefits, the policy goal is the same: families should not have to choose between working and giving their children the care they deserve. Families need time, stability, and economic security. These are not simply expenditures; they are investments in the future fabric of society.
JG: You’ve taken measures on school meals, healthy food regulations, and local procurement. What can a dense global city learn from that?
PB: Spain’s cities’ general proximity to agricultural producers is a structural advantage New York might not share. But the lesson is not about geography, it’s about political will. In Spain, we reformed school meals to be healthier, more sustainable, and more affordable. We’ve pushed regulation to limit unhealthy food in hospitals and care homes, including those in vending machines. And we have supported shorter supply chains wherever feasible—public institutions must use their purchasing power to reduce costs and promote healthier outcomes.
Specifically, our regulation on Healthy and Sustainable Canteens requires that at least 45 percent of fruits and vegetables be seasonal and 5 percent come from organic production. These figures are further increased in the new analogous regulations we’re pushing for hospitals, nursing homes, and all types of public centers, reaching 90 percent for seasonal produce, alongside 10 percent organic production and 10 percent sourced through short supply chains.
These regulations aim to replicate and scale sustainable, high-quality, and local food production and supply models already operating in dozens of schools across various Spanish regions. Notable examples include the “Ecocomedores” project in the Canary Islands and the “Horta Cuina” project in the Valencian Community. These initiatives have achieved fair prices and greater stability for farmers, less pollution in production and distribution methods, a reduction in food waste, and an overall improvement in service quality and the design of healthier menus.
The differences between Spain and New York are significant, but we do share our political goals: that the health and well-being of people, especially children, should not depend on which postal code they live in or the family into which they are born. Advocating for access to healthy food is a matter of basic equality, and that is where efforts should be focused.
JG: Spain is renowned for investments in renewable energy and its mass transit systems. What’s the connection between these policy areas?
PB: Free or heavily subsidized public transit is a climate policy, a social policy, and an economic policy all at once. Spain’s investment in renewable energies and the wider energy transition is rooted in the understanding that mobility must be both accessible and sustainable. We have implemented national subsidies for public transportation, making fares significantly cheaper—and in some cases free—for youth and regular commuters.
Beyond subsidies, from a Consumer Affairs perspective, we are taking decisive regulatory action regarding fair transit as well. Just last week, we approved a regulation on transparent pricing to protect consumers during emergencies. We have also issued sanctions against airlines that fail to comply with consumer rights. Moreover, we have participated in CPC (Consumer Protection Cooperation) actions to tackle corporate greenwashing in the aviation industry and, through our Sustainable Consumption Act, we are moving to prohibit advertising related to fossil fuel, short-haul flights and vehicles powered exclusively by fossil fuels.
In conclusion, environmental targets and consumer rights protections are deeply interconnected; ensuring that both advance together is essential to a fair and transparent green transition.
JG: A final question. You wrote in an article on Mamdani’s primary victory for a Spanish newspaper that societies should not have billionaires. Here in New York, regular people share the city with something like 120 billionaires. How do you think about governing in global cities with such extreme degrees of inequality?
PB: It requires understanding that extreme wealth is a symptom of economic imbalances. When a small number of individuals accumulate fortunes that exceed the budgets of entire cities if not nations, those individuals inevitably exert outsized influence over housing markets, political agendas, and public priorities. Saying “we should not have billionaires” isn’t just a catchy slogan we picked up to cheer on Mamdani’s then-freshly-launched mayoral run. It is a genuine call to debate how we tax wealth, regulate certain industries, and invest in public goods. It means asking what kind of society you want to be. In Spain, our approach has been to regulate the sectors where concentrated wealth does the most harm, such as housing, energy, or digital markets, while building universal systems of social protection that reduce inequality. As Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has said on several occasions, we can have democracy ruled by the people, or controlled by the oligarchs; but we can’t have both.



